Reddit commenting: how to comment and stay up.

Reddit commenting is how most accounts earn their first karma and their standing in a community. This guide covers why a comment fails, how to keep it up, and how Redditors get paid for Reddit commenting on Karma.

Why can’t I comment on Reddit?

The usual causes are a new account, too little karma for that subreddit’s filter, an unverified email, a ban from that community, or a locked thread. A subreddit’s rules often state its minimums.

Why was my comment removed?

A moderator or an automatic filter took it down, usually for a rule the subreddit lists in its sidebar. New accounts, links and repeated text are the most common triggers.

How do you search Reddit for comments?

Open a profile’s comments tab to scroll someone’s history, or use Reddit’s search and switch the results to comments. To find your own, go to your profile and open Comments.

How do you earn comment karma?

Answer questions early in threads that are still growing, in subreddits you know well. Useful, specific comments collect upvotes, while one line jokes in crowded threads rarely do.

What makes a good Reddit comment?

It answers the question, gives a real detail from your own experience, and matches the tone of the community. Read the top comments in a thread before you write yours.

What are the basic rules of Reddit commenting?

Skip pasted text, links to your own things and anything that reads like an ad. Each subreddit adds rules of its own, so read its sidebar before you comment.

Can you get paid to comment on Reddit?

Yes. On Karma, Reddit commenting for a brand campaign earns a fixed fee for each comment, and you write and publish it from your own account.

What if none of my comments show up?

Check them from a logged out window: if your comments are missing everywhere, your account may be shadowbanned. Our Reddit shadowban guide explains how to check and appeal.

How long should a Reddit comment be?

Long enough to answer the question with one real detail, which is often two or three sentences. A long comment does well when every line adds something.

Can you edit or delete a Reddit comment?

Yes, from the menu under the comment, on the web or in the app. Deleting removes your name and your text, though the replies to it stay in the thread.

Can you mention a product in a comment?

Yes, when it answers the question and you say how you know it, since honest experience is what readers trust. Most subreddits remove comments that only push a product or carry a link to it.

How should a new account start commenting?

Start in large, welcoming subreddits with low karma limits, answer a few questions well, and read each community’s rules first. The karma from those comments opens up subreddits with stricter filters.

Should you reply to replies?

Yes, when someone asks a follow up question or adds something worth answering. A short, useful reply keeps the thread going and shows you are a real member.

Why do some subreddits need karma to comment?

Karma limits keep out spam and brand new accounts, so each community sets its own minimum. Comment in friendlier subreddits first to build it up.

Which threads are best to comment in?

Threads that are still growing, in subreddits you know, where someone asked a question you can answer. Early, useful answers get read the most.

Create a Redditor account